ON THIS DATE (35 YEARS AGO)
April 30, 1977 – The Moody Blues: Caught Live + 5 is released in the UK.
# ALL THINGS MUSIC PLUS+ 4/5
# allmusic 4/5
Caught Live + 5 is a Moody Blues double album consisting of a December, 1969 live show at the Royal Albert Hall and five previously unreleased studio recordings from the same time period. It was released on this date in 1977 in the UK (June 4, 1977 in the US).
While Caught Live + 5 managed to reach #26 during its American chart run, it missed the British listings completely, the first time this had occurred for The Moody Blues since their 1965 debut The Magnificent Moodies.
This is the first Moody Blues album since Days of Future Passed not to feature cover artwork by Philip Travers. Decca Records instead used British art design group Hipgnosis.
The band have expressed their dissatisfaction with their performance that night, citing drug use that impaired their abilities, and as such, the release was desired more by Decca Records, who distributed The Moody Blues’ Threshold Records label, than by the band themselves. Nevertheless, the concert showcases the band’s versatility on different instruments, and their ability to perform complex material from their first four albums in a live setting. “Gypsy” is the only representative of the contemporary album To Our Children’s Children’s Children.
The 8-track tape version of this album has the distinction of being one of the few 8-tracks that is arranged exactly like the album, with no song breaks.
by Bruce Eder, allmusic
The Moody Blues released this live concert recording (augmented by some previously unissued studio cuts) after they’d decided to re-form at the end of the 1970s, in order to get some product out and test the waters for their reunion the following year. As their first new release in five years, it sold extremely well on both sides of the Atlantic and fueled the anticipation attending the release of the Octave album a year later. In point of fact, however, the group supposedly never liked the concert much as a document, which is one reason why they didn’t authorize its release on CD until 1996 — the unofficial word among fans is that several of the group members were under the influence of controlled substances during the show and were, thus, less sharp than they might otherwise have been, though you’d never know it from the results here. The 1969 Royal Albert Hall show sounds a lot better on this CD than it did on the LP version, with a closeness that was never evident before — Justin Hayward’s guitar and Mike Pinder’s various Mellotrons, in particular, sound really crisp, and all of the singing comes out with more detail as well. Their repertory at this time came primarily from Days of Future Passed, In Search of the Lost Chord, and On the Threshold of a Dream, plus “Gypsy,” the one number from To Our Children’s Children’s Children — their then new album — that they actually performed live; the latter is also the opening number, and Hayward’s guitar work is most impressive, whether he’s playing the melody in the opening, or crunching out chords on the break. “The Sunset,” from Days of Future Passed, is a showcase for Pinder’s Mellotrons, the keyboard player slowly weaving lush Arabesques and misteriosos while Hayward strums out muted chords, Graeme Edge’s drums impersonate the sound of a tabla, and Ray Thomas’ flute hovers above it all with its lilting phrases. “Dr. Livingston, I Presume” lightens the tone with a more witty, whimsical side of psychedelia that still allows Pinder a chance to show off the Mellotron’s range and Hayward a surprisingly hard-rocking solo — one audience member, in particular, seems taken with it all, punctuating the crescendos with shrieks of appreciation that don’t detract a bit from the listening. Edge’s nimble playing is most impressive on “Peak Hour,” a frenetically paced number off of Days of Future Passed, and the other highlights of the set include the hits “Tuesday Afternoon” and “Nights in White Satin,” and the closing suite from On the Threshold of a Dream, which works well despite Pinder’s being limited to just two keyboards — one scarcely misses the grand piano, and the opening sequence, “Are You Sitting Comfortably,” gives Thomas’ flute its best showcase. The group is tight throughout, both in their playing and singing, and the show ends on a hard-rocking note with “Legend of a Mind” and “Ride My See-Saw” — and the former is a great vehicle for John Lodge’s bass work. The CD mastering reveals details in the playing (particularly on the guitar parts) that were obscured on the original LP, and while there are still occasional balance problems, as a representative set for the band from their psychedelic period, the concert portion of this CD holds up extremely well — one only wishes that the band had seen fit to record a show or two from the following tour, where they rocked out on numbers like “Tortoise and the Hair,” or their 1972-1973 tour behind the Seventh Sojourn album, representing their peak from this era in their history. As for the studio cuts, they’re salvaged from failed album sessions in 1967 and 1968, and they’re not bad songs — “Gimme a Little Something” has a great opening verse, guitar part, and chorus, even if it doesn’t quite hold together perfectly as a song, and “King and Queen” and “What Am I Doing Here” both have hauntingly beautiful melodies. But they’re also not quite up to the standard of what the group released during that period, and work best in a historical, archival context, which is how they were issued.
Tracks 1–14 are live. Tracks 15–19 (side Four) are studio recordings.
“Gypsy (Of a Strange and Distant Time)” (Justin Hayward) – 4:03
“The Sunset” (Mike Pinder) – 4:33
“Dr. Livingstone, I Presume” (Ray Thomas) – 3:23
“Never Comes the Day” (Hayward) – 5:39
“Peak Hour” (John Lodge) – 5:13
“Tuesday Afternoon” (Hayward) – 4:51
“Are You Sitting Comfortably?” (Hayward, Thomas) – 4:21
“The Dream” (Graeme Edge) – :58
“Have You Heard (Part 1)” (Pinder) – 1:22
“The Voyage” (Pinder) – 3:37
“Have You Heard (Part 2)” (Pinder) – 2:33
“Nights in White Satin” (Hayward) – 5:55
“Legend of a Mind” (Thomas) – 7:05
“Ride My See-Saw” (Lodge) – 4:28
“Gimme a Little Somethin'” (Lodge) – 3:13
“Please Think About It” (Pinder) – 3:41
“Long Summer Days” (Hayward) – 3:12
“King and Queen” (Hayward) – 3:52
“What Am I Doing Here?” (Hayward) – 3:33